Five Rules My Dying Patients Made Me Promise to Tell You

Dear young people,

For thirty years I have asked my patients one question, usually near the end, when the tests are done and the truth is sitting between us. Looking back, what rules of life are non-negotiable? What would you tell someone young?

The answers came from truck drivers and CEOs, grandmothers and men with two months left. Different lives. The same five answers, over and over, until I stopped writing them down and started living them. This week, with the shofar a few days away, I am giving them to you.

1. Face the thing you keep not facing.
The unforgiven father. The loss you never sat down and cried for. The fear you buried under achievement. Not one patient ever told me they were glad they avoided it. Every one of them said it followed them anyway, into their marriages, their bodies, their children, and they called it bad luck. What you refuse to look at does not leave. It drives, and you sit in the back seat wondering why you keep arriving at the same place.

The first thing the shofar does on Rosh Hashanah is interrupt. It is not music. It is a cry designed to wake someone who has been sleeping with their eyes open. The very first question God asks a human being in the Torah is Ayeka, where are you? Not because He does not know. Because Adam is hiding, and hiding is the one thing that cannot be forgiven until it stops. This is the week to answer the question. Where are you, really?

2. Know your own darkness.
The people at peace in my office were never the ones who pretended to be harmless. They knew exactly what they were capable of. Their envy, their rage, their hunger. And they chose better anyway, every day, on purpose. The ones who denied their darkness leaked it. Sarcasm. Bitterness. The sweet poison of judging everyone. Here is the secret they finally admitted: the trait you cannot stand in others is usually living in you. Meet it before it meets you.

On Rosh Hashanah we do not stand before the Judge as saints. We stand as people with a full record, and we say it out loud. The tradition does not ask you to be clean. It asks you to be honest. Even tashlich, casting bread into the water, only works if you first hold the bread in your hand. You cannot throw away what you will not admit you are carrying. Name your darkness this week. Then let the river have it.

3. Becoming yourself will cost you people. Pay it.
This was the most common regret I heard. They stayed small to stay loved. They chose the room over the growth. They spent decades as the version of themselves that the family, the marriage, the company required. The ones who had made peace had done the opposite. They disappointed people. They were misunderstood. They outgrew friendships that had once been everything. They told me it was lonely for a while, and then it was real. Loneliness is not always a sign you are broken. Sometimes it is a sign you are finally you.

The rabbis call Rosh Hashanah the birthday of the world, but more precisely the birthday of the first human being, made alone. Before there was a community, there was a soul standing by itself before its Creator. That is where every year begins again. Not with who your parents expected, not with who your friends assume, but with the single unrepeatable person you were sent here to be. The Book of Life does not have a page for the version of you that other people wanted. Only for you.

4. Take the costume off at home.
Everyone needs a role. The strong one. The successful one. The one who has it together. My patients told me the role opened every door and then locked them inside. That tiredness you carry, the kind sleep and vacations cannot touch, is not laziness. It is the exhaustion of performing yourself. Make sure at least one person on this earth knows you without the costume. If nobody does, you are not loved. Your role is.

There is a reason we call this day Yom HaZikaron, the Day of Remembering. God remembers who we actually are underneath the year of noise. In the Unetaneh Tokef we are told we pass before Him like sheep, one at a time, counted. No titles. No résumé. No followers. Just the animal and the soul. It is terrifying and it is the greatest relief of the year. For one day you are permitted to stop pretending, because pretending does not work anyway.

5. Your pain is a letter. Read it before you burn it.
As a cardiologist I will say this plainly: sometimes the body is sick and needs medicine, and I prescribe it without apology. But much of the anxiety and emptiness that walks into my office is not a defect. It is an alarm. It is the truest part of you saying, this is not my life. The patients who silenced that alarm for decades regretted it most. Do not just quiet it. Ask what it is pointing at.

The shofar has three sounds. A long unbroken cry. Three broken ones. Nine shattered ones. The rabbis said the broken sounds are the sound of a heart that has finally cracked open. And then, always, the long unbroken note returns. That is the whole message of this season. The breaking is not the end of the story. It is the invitation. Teshuvah does not mean repentance. It means return. Your pain is the map home.

Five rules, from people who had run out of time to lie to themselves.

You have not. The gates are open. Walk through them.

Shana Tova, and Blessings,

Blessings.

Afshine Ash Emrani, M.D., F.A.C.C.
Assistant Clinical Professor, UCLA
David Geffen School of Medicine

Join Our new website

Castle-Connolly Nationwide Top Doctor (Since 2008)
Los Angeles Magazine Super Doctor (Since 2010)
LA Style Magazine Top 100 Doctors in America (2024)

Subscribe to mynewsletter: substack.com/@afshineemrani
Explore my books: Amazon Author Profile