Afshine Emrani, MD
Doctor Recommended · Thinning hair

Thinning Hair: What Has Evidence

Minoxidil first, honest extras. Chosen by Afshine Emrani, MD, cardiologist.

Start with these 3

If you only do three things on this page, do these, one at a time, after checking with your doctor.

Before you buy

Minoxidil has the strongest evidence for hereditary hair thinning. Ketoconazole shampoo is a reasonable add-on. Supplements are optional and modest. Minoxidil affects blood vessels, so report palpitations or swelling.
What I left off. I no longer list biotin, saw palmetto or red light devices. Biotin rarely helps without a deficiency and can make a heart attack blood test read falsely low.

All picks (6)

Doctor RecommendedStrongFrom my Substack
Rogaine

Men's 5% Minoxidil Foam, 3-month

Who it’s for: Men with hereditary thinning at the crown or hairline
Caution: Minoxidil is a blood-pressure drug: report palpitations, swelling or dizziness; caution with low BP.
Cochrane review supports topical minoxidil.
In my words: “Topical minoxidil (Rogaine or generic) — over the counter, 2% or 5%, for both men and women.”
View on Amazon
Doctor RecommendedStrongFrom my Substack
Rogaine

Women's 5% Minoxidil Foam, 4-month

Who it’s for: Women with hereditary thinning at the part
Caution: Minoxidil is a blood-pressure drug: report palpitations, swelling or dizziness; caution with low BP.
Cochrane review supports topical minoxidil.
In my words: “For women, 5% foam is used once daily. Avoid during pregnancy or breastfeeding, and give it at least four months before judging results.”
View on Amazon
Doctor RecommendedLimitedFrom my Substack
Nizoral

Anti-Dandruff Shampoo, ketoconazole 1%, 7 oz

Who it’s for: People with thinning hair and a flaky or oily scalp
Caution: Scalp irritation.
Small study of 2% ketoconazole showed hair density gains similar to minoxidil; OTC is 1%.
In my words: “Ketoconazole shampoo (1% or 2%, e.g., Nizoral) is inexpensive and reasonable to try; the evidence for hair is limited.”
View on Amazon
Doctor RecommendedLimitedFrom my Substack
Handcraft Blends

Rosemary Essential Oil, 4 oz

Who it’s for: People wanting a gentle add-on to minoxidil
Caution: Dilute; patch test.
One 6-month RCT vs 2% minoxidil; dilute before use.
In my words: “Rosemary oil — one randomized trial found it non-inferior to 2% minoxidil.”
View on Amazon
Doctor RecommendedLimitedFrom my Substack
Nutrafol

Women's Balance (45+), 1-month

Who it’s for: Women 45+ who want a studied combination formula
Caution: Biotin can falsely lower troponin tests; curcumin with anticoagulants.
Company-funded RCTs; contains biotin and curcumin.
In my words: “Pumpkin seed oil (~400 mg), saw palmetto (320 mg), tocotrienols, and some multi-ingredient formulas (like Nutrafol) showed modest gains in a few trials.”
View on Amazon
Doctor RecommendedLimitedFrom my Substack
Nutrafol

Women (18-44), 1-month

Who it’s for: Women 18-44 who want a studied combination formula
Caution: Biotin can falsely lower troponin tests; curcumin with anticoagulants.
Company-funded RCTs; contains biotin and curcumin.
In my words: “Pumpkin seed oil (~400 mg), saw palmetto (320 mg), tocotrienols, and some multi-ingredient formulas (like Nutrafol) showed modest gains in a few trials.”
View on Amazon

How I choose

1. Evidence in people. Randomized trials and meta-analyses, not marketing. Every card links to a study when one exists.
2. Safety with heart medicines. As a cardiologist I check blood thinners, BP, statin and diabetes interactions, and I list them.
3. Quality makers. Brands with clear labels, research doses and third-party testing where I can verify it.
4. I leave things off. When the evidence is weak or the risk is real, it does not appear here, even if it sells well.

Evidence grade: Strong consistent trials Moderate some good trials Limited early or mixed Practical a tool, not a treatment

Want this tailored to you? At Los Angeles Heart Specialists in Tarzana I review your labs, medicines and goals and tell you which of these, if any, make sense for you.

Become a patient